Captive Supranationalism: A Constitutional-Analytical Framework for the Domestic Effect of Community Law
Abstract
Objective: This article develops and operationalizes captive supranationalism as a constitutional-analytical framework for understanding how regional legal authority in CARICOM can expand while its domestic operation remains structurally constrained by national constitutional frameworks. Research Design & Methods: A qualitative, doctrinal legal methodology is employed, drawing on constitutional analysis, treaty interpretation, and a critical engagement with neofunctionalism, liberal intergovernmentalism, and constitutional pluralism. The analysis is structured along three layers: constitutional, legislative, and judicial. Findings: Supranational norms within CARICOM are structurally conditioned by three interconnected pillars: (i) implementation dependency; (ii) a persistent enforcement deficit, evidenced by the absence of an autonomous supranational enforcement body; and (iii) the reversible nature of sovereignty transfer. These pillars constrain domestic application by making regional norms contingent upon national legislative action, subject to a lack of autonomous enforcement, and vulnerable to constitutional opt-outs, thereby locating the decisive variable for domestic effect in the constitutional receptivity of the Member State. Contribution: The article provides a constitutionally grounded alternative to classical integration theories. It identifies the constitutional locus of control over the domestic effect of supranational norms as the decisive variable, rather than post-colonial statehood, dualist traditions, or institutional capacity as such. Novelty: Unlike neofunctionalism, liberal intergovernmentalism, and constitutional pluralism, captive supranationalism locates the decisive variable in constitutional control over the conditions of domestic effect, rather than in integration dynamics, state consent, or inter-order dialogue. The concept of captive supranationalism and the analytical variable of constitutional receptivity are new to the regional integration scholarship. They explain the divergence between the development of Community law and its domestic operation in predominantly dualist legal orders.